Skip to main content
NWArkansas.

NWA-score ranking · 15 qualifying spots

The best ice cream in Fayetteville.

Ranked by NWA Score: a single 0-100 trust signal that combines rating quality, review volume, owner verification, and freshness. The full directory of 15 qualifying ice cream lives at /places/fayetteville/c/ice-cream.

  1. 1

    Crème Ice Cream Co.

    83/100

    4.8(333)$· Mission Boulevard

  2. 2

    Otro Rollo

    83/100

    4.8(150)

  3. 3

    Three Crazy Berries

    82/100

    4.7(218)$$· East Fayetteville

  4. 4

    Shake's Frozen Custard

    81/100

    4.6(484)$· Mission Boulevard

  5. 5

    Cold Stone Creamery

    80/100

    4.5(449)$$· Mission Boulevard

  6. 6

    Burton's Creamery

    80/100

    4.5(132)$· Downtown Fayetteville

  7. 7

    TJ's Sandwich Shop

    79/100

    4.4(613)$$· Mission Boulevard

  8. 8

    BoBo's Ribbon Ice

    79/100

    4.4(438)$

  9. 9

    Folklore Gift Shop & Ice Cream

    77/100

    4.9(22)· Square Adjacent

  10. 10

    Crème Ice Cream

    76/100

    4.4(40)· Mission Boulevard

  11. 11

    Insomnia Cookies

    74/100

    3.9(281)$$· Downtown Fayetteville

  12. 12

    Marble Slab Creamery

    74/100

    3.9(188)$$· Mission Boulevard

  13. 13

    DQ Grill & Chill Restaurant

    72/100

    3.7(203)$· East Fayetteville

  14. 14

    Dippin' Dots

    71/100

    4.2(27)$$

  15. 15

    Otro Rollo- Rolled Ice Cream

    67/100

    5.0(4)

Score formula: rating × 10 (max 50) + log₂(review_count + 1) × 5 (max 30) + verified-owner bonus (15) + recent-update bonus (5). Capped at 100. Recomputed at every ISR tick (6h).